RED DYE BANNED IN US
United States food regulators have banned Red Dye 3, a dye used in food, drinks and medicine after evidence found that it causes cancer in rats.
On Wednesday, the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) proscribed the dye based on a 2022 petition by consumer advocacy groups against its use, which had already been banned in cosmetics 35 years ago.
Keep reading
list of 3 items
list 1 of 3
Could eating dark chocolate reduce the risk of diabetes?
list 2 of 3
Norovirus is spiking in the US: What do we need to know?
list 3 of 3
US bans dye Red No. 3 from foods, saying it causes cancer in lab rats
end of list
The FDA said it had taken the action as a “matter of law” after studies showed that the bright red dye had caused cancer in lab rats. The decision, the agency said, was rooted in a statute called the Delaney Clause, which requires the FDA to ban any additive that causes cancer in people or animals.
The dye has already been banned for food use in Europe, Australia and New Zealand, with the exception of certain kinds of Maraschino cherries that are used in cocktails or candied.
In 2011, a European Food Safety Authority study found no safety concerns due to the minimal exposure levels of the cherries containing erythrosine, known as E127 in Europe and Red 3 in the US.
Advertisement
Here’s what we know about the dye and the FDA decision:
Sign up for Al Jazeera
Americas Coverage Newsletter
US politics, Canada’s multiculturalism, South America’s geopolitical rise—we bring you the stories that matter.
E-mail address
Subscribe
By signing up, you agree to our Privacy Policy
protected by reCAPTCHA
What is Red dye 3?
Known as erythrosine, FD&C Red No. 3 or Red 3 is a petroleum-based colour additive used to give sweets and some cough syrups a cherry red colour.
In 1990, the FDA banned the use of the dye in cosmetics and non-oral medications, including pain relief creams, after a study showed that it caused cancer when it was eaten by rats.
In 2022, several consumer organisations and scientists petitioned the FDA to finally ban all remaining uses of Red 3. In November 2024, nearly two dozen Congress members sent a letter to the FDA officials demanding a ban on the dye.
But the decision taken by the organisation also comes amid US President-elect Donald Trump’s choice to lead the country’s health agency, Robert F. Kennedy Jr., calling for the ban on food additives and chemicals.
Yet, despite the backlash, Red 3 still appears in the ingredients of popular US snack foods and cakes, including Betty Crocker’s Red Decorating Icing and Brach’s Candy Corn sweets.
What has the FDA said?
In a statement announcing the decision on Wednesday, the FDA said it was “taking action that will remove the authorisation for the use of FD&C Red No. 3 in food and ingested drugs”.
“Evidence shows cancer in laboratory male rats exposed to high levels of FD&C Red No.3. Importantly, the way that FD&C Red No. 3 causes cancer in male rats does not occur in humans,” the statement added.
However, the FDA cited the Delaney Clause as the reason why the decision was taken to ban the dye despite finding that the way it spreads cancer in rats does not apply to humans.
Advertisement
The clause, which the FDA said was used in 2018 to ban certain synthetic flavours, “prohibits FDA authorisation of a food additive or colour additive if it has been found to induce cancer in humans or animals”.
The organisation said manufacturers that use the dye in food will have until January 15, 2027 to reformulate their products.
For drug makers, products must be reformulated by January 18, 2028, to comply with the ban.
What have manufacturers and consumer groups said about the ban?
The US National Confectioners Association, the leading trade organisation for the US confectionery industry, which is worth $48bn, said in a statement following Wednesday’s announcement that they will “continue to follow and comply with FDA’s guidance and safety standards”.
“Our consumers and everyone in the food industry want and expect a strong FDA, and a consistent, science-based national regulatory framework. We have been saying for years that FDA is the rightful national regulatory decision-maker and leader in food safety.”
The Center for Science in the Public Interest, which pushed the 2022 petition to ban Red 3, praised the decision by the FDA, saying the agency was finally “addressing a decades-long regulatory failure”.
However, the International Association of Color Manufacturers, which calls for the safe use of natural and synthetic colour additives, said while the FDA “remains steadfast in its commitment to upholding the highest safety standards for colour additives”, the amount of Red 3 consumed by rats to cause cancer needs to be considered.
“Science has advanced significantly in the past three decades, and it is now a well-accepted principle that test animals fed additives in high concentrations may produce increased incidences of tumours, but that does not necessarily indicate that the same effects will pertain to humans,” it said in a statement.
What other food additives could a Trump administration target?
Robert F. Kennedy Jr., who awaits his Senate confirmation to take up the position of Health and Human Services secretary, has already set his sights on banning other additives and foods.
In October, Kennedy called for cereal companies to “take the dyes out of their foods”.
But his position on seed oils, which include canola, soy and sunflower oil has come under significant criticism from nutritionists and scientists.
Kennedy claimed that Americans had been “unknowingly poisoned” by seed oils, with beef tallow a better and healthier option.
However, Christopher Gardner, a professor of medicine at Stanford University, told The New York Times that decades of research had proven that seed oils were linked to better health.
He added that suggesting otherwise “just undermines the science”.
Source: Al Jazeera
Advertisement
Related
US firms boost imports ahead of Trump tariffs
Companies built strategic inventories as Trump has threatened to slap tariffs of 10 to 60 percent on Chinese imports.
Published On 15 Jan 2025
15 Jan 2025
Shipping containers
OPINIONOPINION,
No food, no sleep, no hope in Gaza
Even those who are supposed to help and bring relief in Gaza are falling into despair.
Opinion by Olga Cherevko
Olga Cherevko
Published On 7 Jan 2025
7 Jan 2025
Palestinians gather as they wait to buy bread from a bakery, amid the ongoing conflict between Israel and Hamas, in Deir Al-Balah in the central Gaza Strip November 10, 2024. REUTERS/Ramadan Abed
The secret to a balanced diet? Better roads, say scientists
A new study challenges the conventional wisdom that crop diversity alone addresses nutritional deficiencies.
Published On 7 Jan 2025
7 Jan 2025
A local street woman vendor prepares food near an almost deserted road in Vang Vieng, Laos, Sunday, Nov. 24, 2024. (AP Photo/Anupam Nath)
More from News
Trump plans to ‘save’ TikTok from looming US ban
TikTok
Fact-check: Did Gavin Newsom cut $100m in fire prevention funding?
Gavin Newsom
Israel and Hamas reach Gaza ceasefire deal, what are the next steps?
Gaza
‘Very tough to breathe’: Teary Ons Jabeur struggles with asthma on court
Tunisia's Ons Jabeur is bidding to become the first African and Arab woman to win a tennis major [Yuichi Yamazaki/AFP]
Most popular
Israel delays cabinet vote on ceasefire deal; dozens killed in Gaza
Palestinians carry the shrouded bodies of people killed in Israeli strikes in Gaza City
‘Last-minute crisis’: Netanyahu says cabinet will not meet to approve deal
Israel
Bollywood actor Saif Ali Khan stabbed at Mumbai home
(FILES) Bollywood actor Saif Ali Khan poses for pictures during the promotion of his upcoming Hindi-language horror comedy film
‘Russians in Kherson train on civilians’: Deadly drones stalk south Ukraine
Drones are dangerous says a Ukrainian poster in Kherson-1736940580
AboutShow more
ConnectShow more
Our ChannelsShow more
Our NetworkShow more
Follow Al Jazeera English:
Al Jazeera Media Network logo
© 2025 Al Jazeera Media Network
You rely on Al Jazeera for truth an
Comments
Post a Comment